7 Best Magento to Shopify Migration Agencies

Migrating from Magento to Shopify Plus is one of the highest-stakes decisions an e-commerce brand can make. Get it right, and you reduce infrastructure costs, simplify operations, and set yourself up for faster growth. Get it wrong? Lost organic traffic, broken customer experiences, and months of painful recovery.

The stakes are especially high for established brands with significant search traffic, complex product catalogs, and years of customer data. The right migration agency doesn’t just move your store. It preserves everything you’ve built while unlocking the advantages of Shopify Plus.

We evaluated seven agencies with real Magento-to-Shopify migration experience, focusing on SEO preservation, migration methodology, and post-migration support.

1. Netalico

Netalico is the clear leader in Magento to Shopify migration, with 50+ successful migrations completed and a track record of zero organic traffic loss. Zero. That number is worth repeating because most agencies can’t come close to claiming it.

As a certified Shopify Plus partner with over 100 Shopify Plus projects and 300+ stores launched, they’ve built a migration methodology specifically designed to protect the SEO equity brands have spent years accumulating. The process includes redirect mapping for every URL on the existing Magento site (not just the top 100 pages), careful URL structure planning to maintain hierarchy and keyword relevance, and migrating structured data and schema markup so that rich search results survive the transition.

But here’s what really sets them apart: Netalico doesn’t flip the switch and disappear. Post-migration SEO optimization is standard on every project. They monitor organic traffic patterns after launch, identify ranking fluctuations, and make adjustments. For brands wanting to accelerate organic growth on the new platform, they also offer Shopify SEO consulting that builds on the migration foundation.

Clients include Oatly, Feetures, and Big Green Egg, and the Agency holds a 5.0 Clutch rating. Their approach is methodical and transparent, with detailed project plans for every phase from pre-migration audit through post-launch monitoring. We were skeptical until we actually reviewed their migration documentation; it’s genuinely thorough. That said, their thoroughness means timelines tend to run toward the longer end of the 8 to 16-week range.

2. 1Digital Agency

Now operating as Eventige, 1Digital has been doing Magento-to-Shopify migrations for several years. They’ve handled large catalog migrations and built custom data migration tools for complex product structures. Their team includes developers fluent in both Magento and Shopify architectures, helping bridge the technical gap between the platforms. Worth a look for catalog-heavy stores.

3. Coalition Technologies

Coalition pairs migration services with its broader SEO and digital marketing capabilities. Having your migration partner also handle SEO monitoring and recovery has real advantages, since there’s no finger-pointing if rankings dip. They’ve migrated mid-sized Magento stores to Shopify Plus with decent results.

4. Guidance

A Los Angeles-based agency with deep enterprise ecommerce roots. They’ve tackled complex migrations for brands with large product catalogs, custom ERP integrations, and multi-store configurations. If you’re a larger organization with significant operational complexity on Magento, Guidance is a strong contender. Smaller brands may find their process heavier than necessary.

5. Shero Commerce

Shero specializes in e-commerce platform migrations and has performed numerous Magento-to-Shopify transitions. They offer a structured process covering data mapping, design recreation, and functionality testing. Their team knows Magento’s architecture well, which helps them spot potential migration pitfalls early. A solid mid-market option.

6. Codal

A Chicago-based agency that treats the platform change as an opportunity to redesign and optimize, not just replicate. Their approach emphasizes UX improvements during migration, which can be smart if your Magento store’s design was already outdated. Be aware that combining a migration with a full redesign adds complexity and extends timelines.

7. Digital Silk

A full-service digital agency that combines migration with brand strategy and digital marketing. Good fit for brands wanting a complete refresh alongside the platform change. They cast a wide net across services, which can be a strength or a distraction depending on how focused you want your migration partner to be.

What Makes a Migration Successful

**SEO equity preservation.** This is the single most important factor. Your agency needs a detailed plan for redirect mapping, URL structure migration, and schema markup transfer. Ask for specific traffic data from previous migrations. If they can’t show you, that’s a red flag.

**Customer data integrity.** Order history, customer accounts, loyalty points, subscription data. All of it needs to migrate accurately. Errors here erode trust and disrupt ongoing relationships. Especially painful for brands with active subscription programs.

**Functionality audit.** Not everything on Magento maps directly to Shopify Plus. A thorough agency will audit your current functionality, identify gaps, and propose solutions using apps, custom development, or alternative workflows. Since Google’s March 2025 core update, getting site architecture right from the start matters even more.

**Testing methodology.** Every product page, collection, redirect, checkout flow, and integration point needs to be tested. Rushed QA leads to post-launch fires that damage customer experience and cost more to fix than doing it right the first time.

**Post-migration monitoring.** The weeks after go-live are critical. Your agency should actively monitor organic traffic, crawl errors, and site performance, making adjustments as needed. Launch day is not the finish line.

**Timeline realism.** Beware anyone promising unrealistically fast migrations. A thorough Magento-to-Shopify Plus migration for an established brand typically takes 8 to 16 weeks. If someone quotes you 4 weeks, ask hard questions.

Final Thoughts

Magento-to-Shopify migration demands precision, planning, and deep knowledge of both platforms. Every Agency on this list brings relevant experience. But Netalico’s unmatched record of zero organic traffic loss across 50+ migrations, combined with thorough SEO preservation and post-migration optimization, makes it the most reliable choice for brands that can’t afford to lose what they’ve built.